Why Smart Brands Are Prioritising Sentiment Over Clicks

When it comes to social media marketing, brands are obsessed with numbers: reach, likes, shares, and clicks. But there’s one metric that often gets overlooked, and it might just be the most powerful one of all: sentiment.

If you're running influencer partnerships, organic content, or paid ads across platforms like Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, or YouTube, it's time to ask not just “how many people are engaging?” but “how do they feel about it?”

At Pepper, we treat sentiment as a core part of our reporting, both qualitatively and quantitatively. It helps us understand the real story behind performance metrics, and it's a critical layer in how we evaluate brand perception, content effectiveness, and campaign health.

Let’s dive into why sentiment is a game-changer for B2C brands, and how to actually track it.

What Is Sentiment Analysis?


In plain terms, sentiment analysis looks at the tone of your audience’s comments and conversations. Is it positive? Negative? Neutral? Are people loving your new campaign, or rolling their eyes at it?

It uses AI and natural language processing (NLP) to scan text, emojis, reactions, and even video transcripts to decode emotional responses. Advanced tools like Brandwatch, Sprinklr, Talkwalker, and Hootsuite Insights are making it easier than ever to track sentiment at scale.

Why It Matters for B2C Brands

1. Measure Brand Health in Real Time

Sentiment acts as an early warning system. If negative sentiment spikes, it’s often a precursor to a reputation issue. Catching that early allows you to act fast.

Case in point: Microsoft used sentiment monitoring to boost their brand reputation score by 15%, simply by proactively addressing issues surfaced through social listening.


2. Understand the Quality of Engagement

A spike in comments or shares? Great. But are people cheering you on or complaining?

According to Sprout Social, sentiment helps brands “move beyond surface-level metrics” to understand what kind of engagement is actually happening. And with 94% of consumers saying negative reviews make them avoid a business (source), that nuance really matters.


3. Connect the Dots Between Sentiment and Sales

Emotion drives buying decisions. A Harvard Business Review study found that emotionally connected customers are more than twice as valuable as highly satisfied ones. On the flip side, BrandBastion reports that a single negative comment can reduce purchase intent by 30%.

That’s why brands using sentiment to inform content, product feedback, and customer service are seeing stronger ROI.


4. Evaluate Influencer Partnerships

Influencer posts often bring strong engagement, but without sentiment analysis, you don’t know if people loved the content or hated the collab.

According to Oktopost, measuring sentiment in influencer campaigns helps brands mitigate risks, adjust messaging, and ensure a true fit between creator and brand values.


5. Tune Paid and Organic Performance

Whether you're launching a product, testing creative, or running ads, sentiment shows you how it’s landing emotionally in real time.

TikTok’s comment insights dashboard even lets you score sentiment on paid content and compare it to industry benchmarks. If sentiment trends negative, you can pivot messaging before wasting more spend.


Platform Breakdown: Where Sentiment Shines (and Where It’s Tricky)

Not all platforms are created equal when it comes to sentiment tracking. Here's how the major players stack up:

💡 Instagram

A top platform for B2C brands, and a goldmine of sentiment signals via comments, emojis, and captions. Tools like Hootsuite Insights analyze these inputs to deliver emotional breakdowns like joy, anger, and love.

Instagram Stories and DMs are trickier due to limited access, but with UGC, brand mentions, and hashtag listening, you can still get a rich picture.

💡 TikTok

Fast, reactive, and full of audience feedback. TikTok comments provide valuable sentiment signals. Tools like Brandwatch for TikTok analyze these in real time, and some platforms even use AI to assess video tone and facial expression for broader emotional cues.

💬 Facebook

A longstanding pillar for social marketers. Facebook still offers strong sentiment tracking via post reactions (👍❤️😡😢), comments, and shares. You can monitor sentiment on both paid and organic content, and with integrations like Sprinklr, filter by audience, emotion, or even product references.

🐦 X (formerly Twitter)

X is unmatched for real-time public sentiment. With open APIs and direct user commentary, it's a go-to platform for crisis monitoring, product feedback, and tracking campaign buzz, especially during launches or cultural moments.

📺 YouTube

Great for assessing product reviews, influencer partnerships, and ads. Tools can analyze like/dislike ratios, video transcripts, and comment sentiment to get a full picture of how content is landing.

👻 Snapchat (Trickier, but Possible)

Snapchat is more private and ephemeral, which makes it harder to track sentiment at scale. However, it's not impossible.

  • You can analyze public Spotlight content and story mentions.
  • Monitoring screenshots, swipe-up rates, and poll responses from creator campaigns gives indirect sentiment signals.
  • Some influencer platforms now provide first-party analytics from creators, including audience reaction data.

At Pepper, we work closely with creators and use a combination of custom tracking links, poll response data, and qualitative insight to evaluate sentiment even on more limited platforms like Snapchat.


Sentiment Tracking in Practice: How We Do It at Pepper

Sentiment is a foundational layer of our reporting, not just a nice-to-have. At Pepper, we monitor sentiment across all major platforms and use it to guide:

  • Campaign effectiveness (what’s resonating emotionally)
  • Influencer partnerships (is the reaction genuine and positive)
  • Brand health tracking (is public perception moving in the right direction)
  • Real-time issue detection (are we catching negative feedback early)

We combine quantitative metrics like sentiment score and share with qualitative insights, surfacing the themes, tone, and real customer voices behind the numbers.

This balance helps us uncover what your audience really feels, and what it means for your brand.


Final Thoughts

Tracking social sentiment isn’t just about managing your brand’s reputation, it’s about building a better brand.

When you understand how people feel, you can:
✅ Build content that connects
✅ Choose the right creators
✅ Improve products and messaging
✅ Respond with authenticity
✅ Drive long-term loyalty and ROI

So the next time you check your social stats, don’t stop at impressions or CTR. Look for the emotion behind the engagement.

Cultural relevance and emotional resonance drive the results that matter.

posted on:
May 15, 2025
written by:
Share today
2 women n cut-through of Pepper's P icon
Partner
with
Pepper

Add some spice to your next campaign.

Let's chat
Our

Insights.

Why Saves & Shares Are Social Media's Secret Weapon

Saves, shares, and sales, not likes, are the real engagement drivers. Discover why they’re the secret sauce of influencer success.

Read more

Protecting the Next Generation of Creators: Why the Industry Needs to Act Now

As seen on ITV News, we're calling for better protections for kidfluencers. Join the Responsible Kidfluence Pledge and take our short survey.

Read more

Influencer Marketing vs UGC: What Works Best in 2025?

Traditional influencer marketing and user-generated content (UGC) have both carved out significant roles in how brands connect with audiences, yet they differ in execution, impact, and suitability depending on campaign objectives.

Read more